Zelda: Ocarina of Time Remake Drops to 95 on Metacritic Thanks to One 70/100 Review
A single 70/100 review from Slant Magazine has knocked the Ocarina of Time remake's Metacritic score from 96 down to 95, and fans aren't happy—especially since the outlet has a history of controversial low scores.
The Ocarina of Time remake just lost a point on Metacritic, and it's all because of one review. Nintendo's The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake had been sitting pretty at a 96 Metascore, looking like a serious 2026 Game of the Year contender. But after a new review dropped, that score has slipped to 95.
The culprit? A 70/100 from Slant Magazine. The review's author decided to zoom out and ask a pretty big question: does Ocarina of Time really need to exist? Using the remake as a jumping-off point, the piece digs into the state of the games industry as a whole.
"So rather than wonder whether Ocarina of Time deserves to exist, it's better to see it as a barometer for where the video game industry currently stands," Slant wrote. "It exists, and it's a good game. It's always been good—it's Ocarina of Time, after all. But it's just another worrying sign that video games haven't actually grown up."
Unsurprisingly, that take didn't sit well with the player community. Fans took to social media to push back, calling it a low score designed purely for attention. "Another classic clickbait review," one player wrote. "There's always someone willing to give a universally acclaimed masterpiece a 6 or 7 just to get eyeballs."
And this isn't Slant's first rodeo. Back in 2018, when Red Dead Redemption 2 was raking in 90+ scores left and right, Slant handed it a 70—one of the few outlets to go low—and immediately faced accusations of chasing traffic with a controversial score. The outlet has a track record of doling out lower-than-average numbers to multiple games over the years.
So here's the debate: is a review like this a legitimate independent voice, or just a play for clicks? Some argue outlets have every right to share a different opinion. Others think it's a pattern of deliberately lowballing big releases to stir up buzz. Either way, the Ocarina of Time remake is still a 95 on Metacritic—which is, you know, pretty darn good.
What do you think—does a 70/100 count as a bold take or just ragebait? Let us know in the comments.
📰 Related Articles
Zelda: Ocarina of Time Remake Ending Was Tuned to Make You Cry
Nintendo reportedly went back and forth on the ending of the Ocarina of Time remake, with the team focused on finally delivering the emotional gut-punch the N64 original couldn't quite pull off.
No Mods Needed: This Zelda Player Made a 30-Minute War Film…
The project shows how far Tears of the Kingdom's building tools can be pushed, inspiring players to try their own ambitious contraptions and cinematic projects.
Wii's 20th Anniversary: The Surprising Truth About Zelda Sal…
This shows how casual games and affordable accessories drove Wii sales, sometimes outselling core titles like Twilight Princess and Skyward Sword.
What the Hylian Shield Backpack Deal Means for Zelda Fans
This deal makes it easy for Zelda fans to show off their fandom while carrying everyday gear, especially with the Ocarina of Time remake sparking renewed interest.
What GTA 6 and Zelda's Success Means for Solo Players
This success challenges the narrative that single-player games are dying and may encourage publishers to invest in solo experiences rather than chasing live service trends.
What a Majora's Mask Remake Rumor Means for Zelda Fans
For players, this means a Majora's Mask remake may not be imminent, but Nintendo's pattern of frequent Zelda releases suggests it could still happen down the line.